Home > Character Development > 9 Reasons why Baby Doll from Sucker Punch is a Mary Sue

9 Reasons why Baby Doll from Sucker Punch is a Mary Sue

Poster for the film Sucker Punch

The film Sucker Punch is a fantasy feast for your eyes. A girl is locked away in a mental asylum by her abusive stepfather where she repeatedly retreats to a fantastical world in her imagination where she and four other female inmates battle monsters, soldiers, dragons, and robots. I couldn’t help watch the film without thinking of the main character (called ‘Baby Doll’) of a Mary Sue character. Here’s my reasons why.

Oh BTW this contains some big spoilers, it’s probably best to have watched the film before reading.

She’s called ‘Baby Doll’

What kind of a name is ‘Baby Doll’ anyway? It’s a word normally used for a girls nightgown or negligee. Mary Sue characters in fanfiction often have names that don’t relate in any way to the story, but sound interesting.

Everyone loves her

The girls in the asylum don’t say how long they’ve been there, but it’s quite a long time. Apparently people have tried to escape before but have died trying. It doesn’t take long before Baby Doll comes up with a plan to escape and immediately everyone wants to help, looking up to her as their saviour.

Baby Doll

Baby Dolls hair and make-up always look perfect

She’s got a rough background

After her mother died Baby Doll was abused by her father, and when she tried to protect her sister by shooting her father, she accidentally killed her young sister instead. Traumatised and furious, her evil father convinced everyone she was insane and dragged her to the asylum. Giving her such a terrible background, this makes her a ‘Sympathetic Sue’, and means we’re forced to be sympathetic towards her.

She’s unrealistically athletic

Like a typical Mary Sue, she’s perfect at everything. She can backflip, somersault, dodge bullets, jump over swords and do many more super cool stunts. Like a Marty Stu, she’s the perfect action hero.

She always has perfect hair and make-up

Baby Doll fights huge monsters, falls great heights, gets battered and beaten around by giants and thrown into stone walls with forces that would shatter any normal Human body. But not only is she fine, but her hair and make-up is still perfect.

She knows how to use many types of gun

At only 20 years old and with no military training, Baby Doll seems extremely adept at many types of guns, including automatics and handguns. This would probably need a good few years of military training to handle the guns, and the military tactics she was using. As we’ve seen, this is one of the traits that makes your character a Mary Sue. Of course, this is mostly just shown in her fantasy scenarios so we can forgive it, but we’ve at least seen she can at least handle a handgun in real life because she shot at her evil father at the start.

Like a Marty Stu, Baby Doll likes to use a sword

Like a Marty Stu, Baby Doll likes to use a sword

She has a sword

Many Marty Stu’s I’ve seen do prefer to use a sword, even in a scifi setting. There’s something more stylish about using a sword than guns, and it definitely looks very cool when you’re doing athletic moves that slash villains from all sides.

Her dancing is amazing

When Baby Doll dances for the first time, everyone is captivated. Every time she dances during the film she captivates everyone and the men think she’s the best thing ever. This is a special ability that’s hyped up so much that it’s almost a superpower in the film. It’s the only distraction the girls can use to collect the items they need to escape.

She sacrifices herself in the end

Just like the original Lt Mary Sue in “A Trekkies Tale” who ran the starship Enterprise while the rest of the crew were stricken by a terrible disease, putting her duty to everyone else above her own health, and then died, Baby Doll gave up her freedom at the end to allow her friend Sweet Pea to escape instead.

In context I know this was a hyper-real film, and most of the film was in Baby Doll’s imagination, so quite literally anything could happen. I’m not at all complaining about the lack of realism. I just wanted to highlight the similarities between this and the traits we think of in Mary Sue character.

We’ve got loads of other articles about Mary Sue characters here. 

  1. Grace
    May 2, 2011 at 7:06 am

    Omg lololol you do realise that when she’s fighting like crazy & doing super human things it’s not real right? You mentioned you know but you still go on about it. Anyway it was an imaginative way of coping with reality. Hell I do it all the time, makes life way more interesting ;D BTW you didn’t mention that all the other girls also come under all these headings.

    Even though I don’t agree that she is a Mary Sue I do agree that the characters could have been developed better. I think the ideas were more important than the people, after all it isn’t even Baby Dolls story (which was obvious from the beginning if you can see the clues), she’s an unreliable narrator. It was a psychological movie that sucker punched you in the end; sadly a lot of people didn’t get it. Glad I did ;D

  2. Emma
    May 20, 2011 at 10:26 pm

    I agree with Grace. Also, Points 4, 5, 6, 7, & 8 are all in her imagination. You did mention that although the use of guns is in the non-real segments, you say she was adept with a gun when shooting at her stepfather. Well, she obviously wasn’t because she accidentally shoots her sister…

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s